• BremboTheFourth@piefed.ca
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    2 days ago

    Yeah, when you change the context of the sentence, the meaning changes too. “A court allows” and “a man allows” aren’t the same thing.

    The court had an issue brought before it. It could either allow or disallow the usage of the maps. There isn’t an in-between. Making a big deal over using “allow” for a court is so mind-numbingly, insufferably pedantic that I can’t believe real people are actually up voting it.

    “Approves” I can see a problem with because it implies that the court has made a final ruling. But being mad about it because of some moralizing nonsense is absolutely ridiculous.

    • howrar@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      2 days ago

      These kinds of small wording differences are one of the most common ways for news outlets to intentionally spread misinformation. If you already know what the current laws are, you’ll know what actually happened. Otherwise, “declines to block” tells you that there exists pressure to prevent something that is currently allowed. “Allows” tells you that it wasn’t previously allowed without their approval and they granted that approval.

      It could either allow or disallow […]. There isn’t an in-between.

      So in summary, there are exactly four "in-between"s.

      • It was previously allowed, and it is still allowed
      • It was previously allowed, and it is now not allowed
      • It was previously not allowed, and it is now allowed
      • It was previously not allowed, and it still not allowed

      Which would map to each of the following respectively

      • “declines to block”
      • “blocks”
      • “allows”
      • “declines to allow”

      What you’re saying is that it should map to

      • “allows”
      • “blocks”
      • “allows”
      • “blocks”

      Which, besides being inconsistent with how those words are used in every day English, also reduces how much information you receive.