You’ve been arguing against Marxists for not doing enough, though, because we correctly recognize that voting will not bring change. If you personally are not organizing in real life, and instead just voting and hoping other people do all of the hard work for you, then you aren’t doing anything at all.
You’ve been arguing against Marxists for not doing enough
I am saying that they don’t help contribute much to overall leftist movements and their lack of willingness to at least vote helps minimize our overall impacts as well. Like you said it happens ever 2years and you can’t spare an evening for it? Are you that busy… and still have not much to show for it?
We can do more than one thing at a time and it is foolish to ignore elections completely.
I am saying that they don’t help contribute much to overall leftist movements
How so? The overwhelming majority of groups that have succeeded in establishing socialism have been Marxists. No electoralist progressives have been capable of establishing socialism and solidifying it, ever.
and their lack of willingness to at least vote helps minimize our overall impacts as well
Marxists do vote, though. As I already proved, PSL runs campaigns. Marxists do not think it is useful for anything other than exposure, however, which is why Marxists stress how important it is to actually do stuff like organizing.
Like you said it happens ever 2years and you can’t spare an evening for it?
If someone can’t, there’s no reason to scold them for it, as it doesn’t make a practical difference.
Are you that busy… and still have not much to show for it?
I don’t know what you mean by this, Marxists have established socialism in numerous countries and control the largest economy in the world by PPP. This is far more than any electoralist has achieved.
We can do more than one thing at a time and it is foolish to ignore elections completely.
Nobody is saying to, though, just that electione cannot bring positive change.
If you personally are not organizing in real life, and instead just voting and hoping other people do all of the hard work for you, then you aren’t doing anything at all.
Marxists do vote, though. As I already proved, PSL runs campaigns. Marxists do not think it is useful for anything other than exposure, however, which is why Marxists stress how important it is to actually do stuff like organizing.
And yet we have individuals like you asking people to just skip out and being counter productive to our overall movements. Show up anyway bud, its only an evening every 2 years (if you are american, but that doesn’t change my point)
I did not say we should skip out on voting there, I said voting is not emphasized by Marxists due to not being capable of delivering results. I don’t know why you think that after centuries of reformists trying to vote for positive change that it will finally happen. Look at Allende, he was voted in and then immediately coup’d for it by Pinochet and the US Empire. Revolution is necessary.
Please show me one example of electoralism resulting in socialists taking power and being able to solidify it. Just one. Please also explain why you believe that this time it will be different and finally work.
I didn’t say its the only way. We should be doing more than one thing at a time you know?
You’ve been arguing against Marxists for not doing enough, though, because we correctly recognize that voting will not bring change. If you personally are not organizing in real life, and instead just voting and hoping other people do all of the hard work for you, then you aren’t doing anything at all.
I am saying that they don’t help contribute much to overall leftist movements and their lack of willingness to at least vote helps minimize our overall impacts as well. Like you said it happens ever 2years and you can’t spare an evening for it? Are you that busy… and still have not much to show for it?
We can do more than one thing at a time and it is foolish to ignore elections completely.
How so? The overwhelming majority of groups that have succeeded in establishing socialism have been Marxists. No electoralist progressives have been capable of establishing socialism and solidifying it, ever.
Marxists do vote, though. As I already proved, PSL runs campaigns. Marxists do not think it is useful for anything other than exposure, however, which is why Marxists stress how important it is to actually do stuff like organizing.
If someone can’t, there’s no reason to scold them for it, as it doesn’t make a practical difference.
I don’t know what you mean by this, Marxists have established socialism in numerous countries and control the largest economy in the world by PPP. This is far more than any electoralist has achieved.
Nobody is saying to, though, just that electione cannot bring positive change.
If you personally are not organizing in real life, and instead just voting and hoping other people do all of the hard work for you, then you aren’t doing anything at all.
And yet we have individuals like you asking people to just skip out and being counter productive to our overall movements. Show up anyway bud, its only an evening every 2 years (if you are american, but that doesn’t change my point)
Show me exactly where I say we should skip out entirely. Show me exactly how I am being counter-productive.
And you won’t get the results you want because you don’t show up to vote. Aka, you are being counter productive to your own ends.
I did not say we should skip out on voting there, I said voting is not emphasized by Marxists due to not being capable of delivering results. I don’t know why you think that after centuries of reformists trying to vote for positive change that it will finally happen. Look at Allende, he was voted in and then immediately coup’d for it by Pinochet and the US Empire. Revolution is necessary.
Please show me one example of electoralism resulting in socialists taking power and being able to solidify it. Just one. Please also explain why you believe that this time it will be different and finally work.
A revolution could also be coup’ed therefore we should not make one by your own logic.