• 12 Posts
  • 480 Comments
Joined 7 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 19th, 2024

help-circle



  • Validity of theory isn’t based on what its writers do, but on what its students do. It’s a social science and without practical application it is absolutely worthless.

    Marx, Engels and Lenin have been proven right by the practice of Marxist-Leninists, it isn’t the rule that the best theorists are also revolutionary leaders, but revolutionary leaders by their success prove the worth of the theory they applied to their circumstances.

    I’ve never met a Bordiga follower whose achievements amount to more than writing in opposition to AES. You didn’t need to read leftcoms for that.





  • Capitalism spent centuries being the secondary mode of production under feudalism before the bourgeoisie had developed the productive forces enough to transition away from feudalism. The USSR, Albania and others attempted to force a socialist mode or production before the productive forces were sufficiently developed and it didn’t work. China’s strategy of development of the productive forces has had very little downside and I think it’s unreasonable and kind of suspect to want them to turn back (to policies that ultras would also condemn for one reason or another, as they always do). Poverty fetishism isn’t Marxist and isn’t scientific.

    Or you could just read The State and Revolution where Lenin goes into it for about a hundred pages. It’s been out for over a century.










  • Grapho@lemmy.mltoMemes@lemmy.mlIt's complicated
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    13
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    22 days ago

    Peak lib brained statement. Does nobody have to die for it to be a murder?

    Not that your assumption is any less false, there is zero evidence of genocide in Xinjiang, there is an open campaign against fundamentalist radicalization driven by US proxies which had resulted in some of the most deadly terror attacks in the world for more than a decade. The way such a campaign is conducted is via community outreach, job programs and (in cases where people have already been radicalized) reeducation.

    These programs have been lauded by the Arab League as an example to be followed in the fight against terrorism. But if you have any evidence (actual evidence, not war-profiteer ASPI citing fascist evangelical Adrian Zenz and satellite pictures of nondescript buildings) I’d like to see it. Because if you don’t have evidence but are happy to tell others that it’s happening, you might want to examine your gullibility and whether it’s driven by sinophobia.



  • It is not a bold claim. Israel was from the outset an European colonial project which gained support from the US and Britain to gain a satellite in West Asia, as its unsinkable aircraft carrier/missile platform. The huge amounts of “aid” that has been given to them from its inception should be ample proof (whomever pays for the band picks the music) but US politicians aren’t shy about it either, as with Biden

    Were there not an Israel the United States would have to invent an Israel


  • We can think of a better system that the USSR or USA.

    Not by listening to anarchists in the imperial core. If y’all can’t be trusted not to sling mud at the guy under whose leadership the Nazis were stopped (and who repeatedly tried to stop them before they got as powerful as they did) then I don’t trust y’all with anything else regarding politics.

    In short, this isn’t a glowing report of Stalin’s achievements.

    Of course it’s not. It’s an internal report by the CIA regarding the political situation in the USSR.

    reflects the legacy of Stalin’s crackdowns on dissent and internal opposition

    Oh no, if only they’d let CIA agents run amok in the name of freedom and democracy.