cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/31045336
By Hannah Feuer May 30, 2025
"Rosenthal introduced an amendment that would have required public schools to display the Jewish and Catholic versions of the Ten Commandments, in addition to the Protestant version, which all have slightly different wording. The amendment’s failure to pass, he argued, showed the hypocrisy of the bill’s supporters.
“The fact that they will argue it’s only about values and not about religion, I think it’s a pretty disingenuous talking point,” he said. “The whole thrust of this, I think, is to get a case in front of a newly formed Supreme Court.” The U.S. Supreme Court has had a 6-3 conservative majority since 2020."
some of them are pretty reasonable, but others are just outdated, even from a pragmatic “rules for society” sense.
Murder, theft and perjury? Bad, shouldn’t do 'em. Adultery? Super shitty, no argument. Not sure it’s in the same order as murder, or even petty theft.
Coveting, or more modernly called “embracing feelings of strong envy”? Isn’t that just saying not to do the thing that causes stealing sometimes? It’s not really a societal thing, just a life tip.
Honor your parents? Maybe, but some people have really shitty ones, so being sent to hell for not obeying your abusive Dad is actively cruddy. I’ll charitably accept it as “care for the elderly”.
That’s something like 50% that I’d call good rules. Most of the rest are just “God says to like God”.
deleted by creator
Those could be useful in case some tyrant takea over and says he’s your god now, like he’s some Egyptian pharaoh building gold statues to himself…it’s a declaration of independence for another age :D
…not that modern fanatics could ever reach that conclusion, they couldn’t spot satan even if it were telling them to vote for him to punish the unbelievers.