• 4 Posts
  • 193 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 15th, 2023

help-circle
  • I’m surprised P ended up that high, the amount of autotune in it sounds like AI speech synthesizer with articulation cranked all the way 11 where it just makes random weird sounds

    59.1% AI-detection™ score

    A small note: that I wasn’t trying to decide whether something was AI, I was trying to evaluate its creativity. So I actually thought A was real, but that it was extremely generic… I also suspected D was AI but trying to judge on creativity, I was unimpressed with the lyrics (not that creative) but I found the soundscape it created interesting. That’s a place where my (un)familiarity with the genre was a liability. I also found the pitch of “you” in “who are you” nrar the end to be creative, like in the wrong key but in a good way.

    Also I only listened to each track once, then decided where to put it in the list. Like “top”, “bottom”, “near bottom but not worst”. And I placed them as I went. If I went through the list again I’d probably swap some but that would have taken way longer and I decided it was more important to be done. I probably should have done some spot checks at the end to make sure things ended up where I wanted.



  • IVQJHOUPLGCFDNERTSMBKA

    Great work. A few thoughts re: methodology.

    • I despair for society’s musical inclinations.
    • Not being able to understand the lyrics was a big impediment.
    • Not being familiar with/fond of the genres was a big impediment.
    • given those two limitations I think I may have inadvertently selected for intra-song diversity and that may favour AI generation since it’s a lot more work for musicians to change sounds in the middle of a song.

    I’m very curious to see the results. Sorry I didn’t get to it sooner.