• 2 Posts
  • 39 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 26th, 2023

help-circle
  • I think one of the big problems with every methodology, and every attempt to come up with a unified vulnerability or threat ontology, is that a security problem can also be “whatever the user doesn’t like.” These types of things always run into problems caused by the mixing of syntactic and semantic threats, without attempting to distinguish between the two.

    Then every threat library derived from these doomed ontologies end up either over complex or insufficiently complex to represent the problem set. At least that’s my take. I could be wrong.

    Adding in the VSM actually makes things a lot easier, because all your threats will align through viability. So then a threat can be more formally defined as “Any behavior systemic of the system under test that threatens the viability of the parent system, given that the behavior can be intentionally invoked.”

    The VSM also just happens to be a threat model, though it never seems to be described as such.


  • I’m reading “Brain of the Firm” and working on a threat modeling methodology, actually. I worked on one that’s been used a bit internally at work. It allowed us to threat model before design. That provided a framework to guide design and support implementation, rather than just checking those things when they were done.

    It has some similarities to Trike (at least as I understand it). That probably shouldn’t be surprising since I worked for Mike Eddington for a while in the 2010’s. It starts with something very similar to the trike requirements model, but isn’t restricted to CRUD. It also added an additional “constraint” field which was free text. It was really powerful, but could be hard to use. One folks learned it, they were able to get great results. The best thing is that TPMs and product owners, not security folks, owned the first step. By including them in the process, the whole product team started to think in a more adversarial way. But it was always missing some stuff. The hardest thing is figuring out what level of abstraction to model. It also never had a good threat library.

    Since digging into the Beer’s Viable System Model, I think I’ve figured out a lot of additional things. There are still some gaps. All of this was happening before LLMs, and a lot of the manual work was mutating triplets. The whole thing was designed with formal language in mind (some folks suggested ACE). With LLMs the text manipulation is pretty easy, and formal language may not be necessary. Integrating VSM can clarify what level to model, while still providing recursion to model at a deeper level.

    I’m also thinking about integrating the OODA loop. The whole idea of threat model then test has always been a problem for me. There’s a natural interplay between your observations, how they fit in to what you know (orientation), which things you then prioritize to test (decide), and how you formulate your action into a hypothesis.



  • Exactly. His relationship with the US is just as cynical as it is with Russia, and as it is with any country or people (including his own). He will do or say anything that gets him more power. That means he’ll be a solid US ally as long as the US is completely stable and functional, and he will take advantage of any weakness (like he did with Trump letting him murder Kurds in Syria).

    I think we’re in violent agreement about the overall with perhaps subtle difference in the details.


  • Erdogan has been close to Putin for a long time. He’s one of the most extreme authoritarians in the NATO alliance. The US has armed it’s enemies in the past, and I don’t think it’s short sightedness has changed.

    I don’t believe that Erdogan will help Palestinians, but he very well may materially support Hamas as long as he doesn’t do it openly enough to cause problems. I mean, Netanyahu propped up Hamas for years in order to forward his interests. No one would care if Erdogan helped justify continuing the genocide by making Hamas more dangerous to Israelis, as long as he didn’t send any American weapons to them.

    But perhaps I’m just extremely cynical.



  • Erdogan is a fascist who’s responsible for genocide in Northern Syria. He doesn’t give a fuck about Palestinians or the genocide Israel is carrying out against them. He is aligned with Hamas and terrorism because disrupts regional power and gives him opportunities. This is an opportunity for him, and nothing more. His government backed Isis before. This is the same.

    It has nothing to do with the very real need to end the genocide of Palestinians or the legitimate desire of Palestinians to resist their oppression. He aligns himself with horrible people because he is himself horrible.



  • But this is really more a product of capitalism than anything else. Under capitalism you just have to keep moving even if you’re just making garbage and debt. There’s no reason to stop and think, because that is seen as a cost (even though it costs more to move without thinking).

    Even the best companies that do factor in planning (at least in concept if not actually in practice most of the time) end up with the other problem of “resume driven development” where things that are totally fine and actually working get replaced with things that don’t work because someone needs a new project to get their promotion.

    Capitalism produces garbage and puts the people who are least qualified in decision making roles. This still happens in natural systems, but much less. In (healthy) anticapitalist organizing, the people who know the most are generally asked to lead and when they don’t know what to do they stop and figure it out before moving forward.

    Aimless wondering can still be a problem, but it’s not forced by the system to continue it’s just people who are learning.






  • If you ever drive through rural America, you’ll usually at least see one or two crosses, often on telephone poles, on rural roads. People, often teenagers, die pretty regularly in rural America because of drunk driving.

    Some people like it. Some people are just numb to it. It’s just insane to expect people not to when bars are the only social space in a lot of these towns, and those bars are not accessible by anything but car. There is no such thing as a taxi for most of the US (space wise, not population wise).




  • A lot of people grew up being used to a safe county. The idea that the government didn’t actually keep people safe, and that leaders could be so insanely incompetent, was so shocking it was easier to believe in crazy conspiracy theories.

    It’s pretty easy to believe in an incompetent government after 9/11, but W came after Clinton and Bush Sr. The first Bush was the head of the CIA. He was evil, but highly competent. Clinton was clearly a world leader, also highly competent. Before that you had Reagan, who was Machiavellian as fuck running secret wars around the world. You had decades of these people looking like they were playing geopolitical 4d chess, then you had this clown who was playing checkers with pidgins. Then you had this incredible shock of the biggest attack on the US since Perl Harbor. It broke a lot of people’s brains.


  • Cars are absolutely going somewhere. Cars won’t exist in 100 years (or will be so rare they will be basically negligible) because either we will have phased them out or they will have brought about the collapse of the complex society needed to support them.

    The problem is not just Internal combustion, but a myriad of issues with the most fundamental and intractable being that the fact that geometry hates cars. Car based society has been an experiment that’s only been going for less than 100 years, and it’s already failed. Even with essentially infinite cheap energy, cities like Detroit and Flint, early adopters of car-centric design, are showing us what the future looks like for any city that doesn’t radically change course.

    There will be massive suffering, reguarless of the course we take. People will lose massive amounts of wealth. Lots of people will die as the collapse of car infrastructure displaces massive numbers of people. The question is only if we aggressively mitigate the impact of the collapse of car culture, or keep pretending that cars aren’t going away and allow the humanitarian crisis to grow beyond the ability of society to absorb, manage, and recover from it.