• 1 Post
  • 1.48K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 17th, 2023

help-circle



  • Boycott.

    But you don’t even want to change which brand of Mac & Cheese you buy, it would inconvenience you too much. The point of your movement is to do performative to gain social media clout, not to do anything that would inconvenience yourselves in any way.

    And yes Kraft is big, maybe boycotting them won’t have much of an effect. But bullying someone smaller like a B-list musical artist also won’t have a big effect in terms of society, but it will have a big effect on that particular musical artist.

    This whole thing proves that you’re movement is weak, you know you’re weak, and you engage in bullying solely to try to convince yourselves that you are strong. You’re too weak to try to take on someone big like Robert Kraft (the real source of this particular controversy), so you don’t even try.

    You’re Karens shouting at the cashier instead of just taking your business elsewhere. The point is to make a scene and bully people, not to do anything real (that’s too much effort!) that will actually make any kind of a difference.



  • The answer is pretty clearly stated:

    It’s wrong, and it isn’t a reflection of the Democrats in the Congress of the United States.

    The issue with a lot of the far left is that “allyship” is prioritized to the point where it’s impossible for anyone to denounce anything or anyone as long as it’s nominally “on our side.”

    on multiple occasions I’ve found leftists that are incapable of even denouncing Hamas, a terrorist organization that has deliberately murdered women and children. Should be very easy to say “I’m pro-Palestine, but I denounce Hamas, those guys aren’t a part of my movement.” But we don’t want to offend any allies so let’s not say anything like that!

    So if you’re in an extreme allyship culture it’s difficult to understand someone saying they don’t want to be associated with someone even if they are on the same side on many issues. The enemy of my enemy is not always my friend.

    Really the pro-Palestinian movement would have a lot more success if it could separate itself from terrorist groups like Hamas and from overt antisemitism. But vibe-based internet movements with no clear goals are incapable of understanding when someone that’s nominally “on your side” is more of a liability than an asset.

    The uncommitted movement are explicitly single issue voters, and GOP is way better at attracting vaguely racist single issue voters into their tent. If the Democratic Party becomes a party that is about appeasing the vaguely racist single issue voters, then how is it any different from the GOP? The typical “both sides are the same” voter suppression tactic becomes true at that point.

    And sure you may be used to being the ones labeling others as being racist and it really stings when you’re the ones being labelled as such. But it’s obvious that while not everyone that’s critical of Israel is antisemitic, all antisemites are critical of Israel. Do you need an Venn diagram? Given the anti-Israel coalition refuses to recognize there is any antisemitism in the ranks (must never reject an ally!), they’re not doing anything about it. Must never criticize those that criticize Israel!

    But yeah criticizing people, even those within the same party is normal. What’s actually weird is being incapable of having any kind of rational response to it, other than to attack. Always attack never defend, the mantra of cults everywhere.

    It’s also obvious that the uncommitted are more comfortable with being allies with Hamas and overt antisemites than being allies with the Democratic party.


  • People have agency.

    You have a strange mix of the “great man” theory and the dialectic theory of how things work. The great man does a thing and people will automatically go down that course of action for decades because of dialectical reasons or whatever.

    It’s really the opposite. The great man can nudge things, but a lot of other people need to continue to make decisions to continue to push things in that direction. At any time people can decide “nah, I don’t think things should continue to go in this direction.” You should consider the reasons why a continuous push to fascism wasn’t rejected instead of latching on to individual actions as being the one and only thing that made fascism inevitable.

    The US has particular cultural issues that make them vulnerable to fascist manipulation. Racism is a big one. The mythology around the past greatness is another big one. There’s also a general paranoia of government, and conspiracy theory culture. Reagan’s little nudges here and there wouldn’t have gone anywhere if there wasn’t an environment for other’s to continue to successfully push towards fascism.

    You need to be careful in doing the thing where “Hitler was nice to his dog, so therefore being nice to dogs causes fascism.”

    Marxism teaches a religious prophecy where it’s inevitable there will be a great cataclysm overthrowing capitalism which will inevitably become corrupt. It’s not too dissimilar to the Christian revelations prophecies, probably why it’s attractive for atheists that were previously in the Christian church. But the truth is, nothing is pre-determined, there is no such thing as “late stage capitalism”, nobody really knows where things are heading, there are not mystical signs you can read to determine if a person is the anti-christ or fascist or whatever you want to label your ideology’s demons.

    Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. Sometimes guy that says they want to lower taxes is a guy that just wants to lower taxes. That doesn’t inevitably lead to an oppressive authoritarian state unless people go along with all of the other steps involved in implementing an authoritarian state.

    And need I point out the fact that socialism has led to authoritarian states in the past? Does that mean we should reject all socialist policies out of hand?


  • Says the fellow carrying water for the regime that kicked this all off nearly 80 years ago

    How old do you think I am?

    It is a distinctly fascist trope to use history books as a justification for present day violence and authoritarian rule. There are right now Russians dying in Ukraine to restore a Soviet Empire that never existed in their lifetime.

    Do you think the ethnic makeup of a region should be restored to how it was before any of us was born? I think if a person was born in a place they have a right to continue to live there. More than 80% of of Israelis were born in Israel. So they have a right to live there, no matter what happened in the past. Thinking a baby should be judged for events of 100 years ago is why atrocities like October 7 occur.

    Hamas has very fascistic blood and soil style beliefs where their ethnicity is entitled to remove people of other ethnicities from a region because the history books say they weren’t there a hundred years ago or whatever. They coat this with a thin veneer of religion (as fascists often do) but at the heart of Hamas is a fascist ideology.

    We’re seeing these fascist beliefs spread into the west. It’s an odd thing where people claim to be leftist but support a fascist organization in another part of the world. This puts into question whether leftism in the west is actually leftism, or just fascists in socialist clothing. It’s fairly common in history for fascists to claim to be socialists. See National Socialism or present day China for examples.

    But you’re not arguing earnestly or in good faith, anyway. If you were, you couldn’t crying about Hamas attacks and oppression of Palestinians while still defending Israel

    You can’t be crying about fascism while defending Hamas. Hamas is fascist, considering Hamas and Palestinians to be one and the same (which is something Netanyahu often does too BTW) is legitimizing fascism. I actually support Palestinians, but I see Hamas as a cancer, the same way I see all fascist movements. You’re trying to spread the cancer, which is obviously harmful to Palestinians. I want both Netanyahu and Hamas gone. Because they both have fascistic character and neither respect the right of people to live where they were born.


  • There are real economic policies that could improve people’s lives. Tax the wealthy, break up large corporations, actually implement healthcare.

    The wealthy want to distract you from these things because they enjoy not paying taxes, controlling huge corporations, and profiting off of you when your sick.

    So they distract you with demagoguery about failed economic systems to keep you ignorant of the policies that will actually work. Guys like Hasan don’t want you to have a better life, they want to profit off of you by selling socialist themed t-shirts at their merch stores.

    No socialist movement can succeed without the working class. The working class know how difficult it was for people like them under socialist systems of the past. It is only the university elite that get scammed by guys like Hasan, he does his performances on a set designed to look like a dorm room after all. You have an affinity to Marx, Lenin, Mao, maybe even Stalin if you’re particularly tankie. The Working class have an affinity towards the people that starved, were worked to death on a “five year plan” or people in China right now working a 996 shift. You’ll probably have to do some googling to figure out what a 996 shift is because you care so little about the working class.

    He’s not using a dime of the money he’s made off of his grift to organize labour, there is zero effort to appeal to the working class in this faux socialist movement. It wouldn’t work anyway because there has been enough contact with people in the working class with people that have immigrated from former socialist countries that they all know the socialist rhetoric is bullshit. Life was worse for the working class under socialism, you hand wave it away as a minor detail, and that makes you toxic to the working class. Only wealthy university kids that haven’t had much contact with the working class buy into the “class consciousness” “late stage capitalism” type rhetoric. The working class knows it’s all a lie, anyone who’s talked to anyone from Eastern Europe or Cuba who was working class and not part of the political elite knows what’s up.

    Hasan represents a movement for psychopaths that ignore the hardships of the people that were oppressed be the authoritarian regimes you regularly quote.


  • Nah, I don’t like MAGA at all, I’m Canadian.

    But I do recognize Hasan is just running a MAGA style grift.

    I also recognize you’re unable to accept any criticism of a wealthy grifter the same way that MAGAs defend Trump, another wealthy grifter.

    You’re upset about the declining quality of life. You should be. THinking some rich guy that’s just saying controversial things on social media is going to make your life better? Feeling like it’s important to vehemently defend a wealthy social media grifter? Yeah that’s what MAGA is really about.

    You’re just being angry about people not liking orange kool-aid and saying they must like the strawberry kool-aid. Y’all are drinking the kool-aid down there. Which flavour you prefer doesn’t make you any better than the other people drinking the social media kool-aid.



  • As you were typing out your comment, who will be leader of Israel will be determined by whether or not an Arab party will be accepted into a governing coalition. They always exclude Arab parties from being in the coalition. Because racism and shit.

    That’s proportional representation. You have lots of options for who to vote for, but if the majority wants to lock out a minority group from power they can. All power is determined by backroom deals between parties.

    But there is a chance the Arab party may be allowed to be part of the government. It all depends on whether the leaders of a bunch of parties are willing to allow Netanyahu to continue to rule over them or allow an Arab party to join them. Nothing anybody can do about it, the lives of a lot of people and the future of the middle East depends on the results of some backroom deals.

    Fuck proportional representation. It’s so obviously a stupid system. If Netanyahu didn’t get enough votes to continue to be PM but he may still continue to be PM because of some bullshit backroom deal, while you watch him do whatever he’ll do next, will you still say “but proportional representation of good?”


  • Proportional representation gives all power to the parties and they decide policy in backroom deals when forming coalitions. It’s the system Israel has. Do you really want to have Israel’s system of government? A lot of oppression can happen when a party has to to make deal with radical nutjobs to form a coalition. Why do you think that’s a superior system? Do you like oppression?

    “First Past the Post” is a term coined by intellectually dishonest people that say they want “electoral reform” when really they just want to change the system so their preferred party will have more power. We should call it what is really is, a community representation system. Because you’re voting for someone to represent your community. But that sounds nice and is more difficult to argue against, isn’t it?

    I’m well aware of instant runoff system, and I think that would be ok. But a two round system is better than instant runoff. S-tier is two round community representation, instant run off community representation is A-tier, one round, one selection traditional community representation is C-Tier.

    Israel style proportional representation only seems good to people who think of things from the perspective of a spreadsheet (the numbers all line up… yay) and have no understanding of power dynamics… F-Tier. Close your spreadsheet and look at how proportional representation works in the real world. How much oppression will you tolerate just so that two columns in a spreadsheet will have the same numbers in them?



  • Social media is all emotional manipulation all the time. Are you capable of thinking of the Gaza war in rational terms or only in emotional terms? Why is it you can only think of it as an emotional issue?

    The social media algorithms send you a constant stream of content that keeps you emotional all the time. They aren’t trying to inform you of anything, they want to keep you emotional so you’ll keep on doomscrolling so they can keep on showing you ads.

    You’ll never know what’s happening in a conflict on the other side of the world. You’ll only get curated emotional content. That doesn’t result in any kind of understanding.

    Constantly consuming this kind of content will turn you into a hateful person. The tech bros don’t care, as long as you keep consuming, they keep making money.


  • Only the “radicalized” think of politics in religious terms. The radicalized are capable of doing horrible things to people because they have a cult-like zealotry that makes them think any action against the supposed enemy is justified.

    The radicalized left and radicalized right are the same kind of people. The enemy is arbitrary. The point of a radicalized movement is to make people stupid enough they will give the demagogue leader all power to defeat the enemy. But in the end it’s all the same, people being oppressed by an authoritarian.

    I have less concern about the most boring man in BC politics oppressing people than I have about people like you who think of politics as being similar a holy crusade against the evil other.




  • After October 7 it will be at least a decade before Israel can come out of bunker mentality. You might be ignoring how horrific the actions of Hamas were on that day. I admit I couldn’t get though all of the horrific things they did that day, it was insane. But Israelis are well aware of what happened. Having millions of people typing on the internet sympathizing with Hamas probably doesn’t help in getting them out of the bunker mentality. We’re still a long way from the truth and reconciliation that’s needed, but any step in that direction (even a baby step) is something that should be welcomed.

    I don’t want to see another Gaza war in a decade or two. We’ve already seen how that works out, it doesn’t go well for anyone, especially for Palestinians. But on the internet it’s just a constant thirst for more violence, as long as it’s someone other than the person posting the comments that’s going to die because of it.


  • All I ever see is propaganda design to foment hatred of Israel which could lead to more violence. Do you think continuing a violent struggle against Israel is making the lives of Palestinians better?

    A non-violent resistance movement would work. Violence obviously doesn’t favour Palestinians.

    A lot of words about destroying Israel, but they have have a lot of firepower that disagrees with your words. But on this site people continue to promote violence towards Israel, all too happy to throw away Palestinian lives purely for the sake of their addiction to hate. You are addicted to seeing images of dead Palestinians so you can get a rush from your daily two minutes of hate.

    It’s obvious to anyone that Israel will not be destroyed by violent acts. That only results in Palestinians dying. I want an end to this war and a Palestinian state living in peaceful co-existence with Israel. Do you want that, or do you want more Palestinians to die while pretending that if you just one more another generation of Palestinian as cannon fodder it will work? Truth and reconciliation is the actual pro-Palestinian stance, not pushing hatred of Israel that will just get more people killed and accomplish nothing.