this deal builds towards a further SDF integration it would be far better not only for Kurds, Syrians in general human rights wise, but also al-Sharaa will have a counter
It’s a delicate balance. Afaik, but I’m not sure, the integration of all parties in the SDF was to lower the risk of future conflict, ensure rebuilding and aid, but also to sort of force the groups to work together. In this, imo Saudis and Turkey want different things. I don’t think anything sharia will help minorities in the future with their Separate religions… And a more moderate way - say initiatives like respecting Kurdish - is the way forward.
The atrocities you mentioned took place before the regime fell ? I thought part of the truce after the Assad regime fell, was that past mistakes were forgiven, including war crimes, or were these recently done?
#add When you say that France & USA are pushing the way, are they translating the Saudi and Türkiye agenda into a sort of one big plan; or are ther actually many coexisting plans?
UPDATE: Syria’s Deputy Defense Minister, Syrian commander of Turkmen origin Fehim İsa, has resigned.
Isa said he resigned in protest of the systematic marginalization of Syria’s Turkmen, in contrast to the positive discrimination and linguistic/cultural rights granted to Syrian Kurds.
I will just post Eli Tsurkov’s comment: " oh no! What will the Syrian Army do without his skills in mercenary work outside of Syria, ethnic cleansing of Kurds, looting, running torture dungeons and protection rackets? "
Nope, after the regime fell. There was an Assadist uprising on the coast in March 2025 where government-aligned forces, overwhelmingly ex-SNA massacres more than a thousand civilians. Druze was Hijri proclaims his authority at the end of March after Syrians in Homs chanted racist chants against Druze and Israeli Druze even started entering to fight in Syria, ethnically cleanses several tribes ( one of them - the Sirhan tribe was almost entirely wiped out in Syria but Jordanian bedouins and forces intervened). Sharaa initially blocked tribes and ary from entering, he then let in angry unorganised tribes that killed Druzes, then the SAA entered and did more violations.
There are a lot different visions of Syria most of which see it as united. Turkey wants 100% Turkish puppet but the US is trying to balance out Israel and Turkey and other actors so that the Middle East is stable. ( Israel did 750 bombings and 125 ground incursions in first 3 months post 08.12.2024( fall of Assad regime), in 7 months - 987 air & artillery strikes, 421 ground incursions, occupied ~180 km^2 of land, had Swuieda as a puppet. There are also Syria-Israel talks and there were recently Turkey-Israeli talks that could lead to more detente. Saudi mostly wants to invent and get Syria aligned with the GCC. UAE is also having a stake in Syria and with the new Saudi-UAE cold war we might see where Syria goes.
Also the links to resources maniacalmanicmania put in the lemmy.world Syria channel he made is amazing. If you want 1 person to listen to Wassim Nasr, who works for France 24 has got you covered.
It’s a delicate balance. Afaik, but I’m not sure, the integration of all parties in the SDF was to lower the risk of future conflict, ensure rebuilding and aid, but also to sort of force the groups to work together. In this, imo Saudis and Turkey want different things. I don’t think anything sharia will help minorities in the future with their Separate religions… And a more moderate way - say initiatives like respecting Kurdish - is the way forward.
The atrocities you mentioned took place before the regime fell ? I thought part of the truce after the Assad regime fell, was that past mistakes were forgiven, including war crimes, or were these recently done?
#add When you say that France & USA are pushing the way, are they translating the Saudi and Türkiye agenda into a sort of one big plan; or are ther actually many coexisting plans?
Tnx for your elaborate answer.
UPDATE: Syria’s Deputy Defense Minister, Syrian commander of Turkmen origin Fehim İsa, has resigned.
Isa said he resigned in protest of the systematic marginalization of Syria’s Turkmen, in contrast to the positive discrimination and linguistic/cultural rights granted to Syrian Kurds.
I will just post Eli Tsurkov’s comment: " oh no! What will the Syrian Army do without his skills in mercenary work outside of Syria, ethnic cleansing of Kurds, looting, running torture dungeons and protection rackets? "
Nope, after the regime fell. There was an Assadist uprising on the coast in March 2025 where government-aligned forces, overwhelmingly ex-SNA massacres more than a thousand civilians. Druze was Hijri proclaims his authority at the end of March after Syrians in Homs chanted racist chants against Druze and Israeli Druze even started entering to fight in Syria, ethnically cleanses several tribes ( one of them - the Sirhan tribe was almost entirely wiped out in Syria but Jordanian bedouins and forces intervened). Sharaa initially blocked tribes and ary from entering, he then let in angry unorganised tribes that killed Druzes, then the SAA entered and did more violations.
There are a lot different visions of Syria most of which see it as united. Turkey wants 100% Turkish puppet but the US is trying to balance out Israel and Turkey and other actors so that the Middle East is stable. ( Israel did 750 bombings and 125 ground incursions in first 3 months post 08.12.2024( fall of Assad regime), in 7 months - 987 air & artillery strikes, 421 ground incursions, occupied ~180 km^2 of land, had Swuieda as a puppet. There are also Syria-Israel talks and there were recently Turkey-Israeli talks that could lead to more detente. Saudi mostly wants to invent and get Syria aligned with the GCC. UAE is also having a stake in Syria and with the new Saudi-UAE cold war we might see where Syria goes.
Also the links to resources maniacalmanicmania put in the lemmy.world Syria channel he made is amazing. If you want 1 person to listen to Wassim Nasr, who works for France 24 has got you covered.