The numbers published by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights: 14,383 killed and 37,541 injured since 2022. The true numbers are probably higher, but this isn’t Gaza.
I’m not saying it is Gaza. No one is. I’m saying they’re doing “Gaza-like” things. A key difference is that Israel essentially shoots Palestinians on sights and have a blatant disregard to human rights and human life.
That’s not to say that Russia is a white knight in comparison.
2 definitions of genocide are forcing transfer of children and removal of national identity.
Putin has stated and played down the national identity of Ukraine. He believes it to be a small subset of russia.
And it is widely reported that children were taken, especially in the first year from invaded areas, and are being adopted by Russian families or placed into boarding or the military.
And if you knew anything of Russian history towards Ukraine, you’d know there is absolutely precedent for these things. People and countries can change, my country for example is very close allies with France despite being absolute bitter enemies for countless centuries. But from listening to Putin and his talk of Ukraine, he has not changed.
This isn’t a matter of technical definition, it’s the crime of crimes. There’s a reason no legal case for genocide has been made, it’s because the standards for it are too high for anything Russia has done to meet.
The numbers published by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights: 14,383 killed and 37,541 injured since 2022. The true numbers are probably higher, but this isn’t Gaza.
I’m not saying it is Gaza. No one is. I’m saying they’re doing “Gaza-like” things. A key difference is that Israel essentially shoots Palestinians on sights and have a blatant disregard to human rights and human life.
That’s not to say that Russia is a white knight in comparison.
That “key difference” is precisely how we can tell that Russia isn’t committing genocide, nor does it intend to.
2 definitions of genocide are forcing transfer of children and removal of national identity.
Putin has stated and played down the national identity of Ukraine. He believes it to be a small subset of russia.
And it is widely reported that children were taken, especially in the first year from invaded areas, and are being adopted by Russian families or placed into boarding or the military.
And if you knew anything of Russian history towards Ukraine, you’d know there is absolutely precedent for these things. People and countries can change, my country for example is very close allies with France despite being absolute bitter enemies for countless centuries. But from listening to Putin and his talk of Ukraine, he has not changed.
Why hasn’t the ICJ opened a case?
This isn’t a matter of technical definition, it’s the crime of crimes. There’s a reason no legal case for genocide has been made, it’s because the standards for it are too high for anything Russia has done to meet.
Calling it genocide cheapens the term.
Well, only SA has an ICJ case of genocide in Gaza, but we all know it is one.
Stop cheapening the term with your far right Russian propaganda.