Im a little confused. Is America actually capitalist, or is it crony capitalist? Would TRUE capitalism have any problems? On the surface, it makes sense: make good product, get money. Someone makes better product, you need to improve yours or you go out of business. The issue is when we get monopolies and regulations that then restrict actual good products from being able to exist. But thats not a thing in true capitalism (so they say)

Is the best thing a mix of socialism and capitalism? I dont think we could abolish government, as someone has to lead. Certainly government needs to have actual checks and balances in place.

  • Štěpán@lemmy.cafe
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    5 hours ago

    The main problem I see is that earth is not infinite. You have finite resources that are “owned by everyone” by their nature, and capitalism’s competitivness incentivizes their destruction.

    World’s countries are allowing companies to destroy the climate, forests, and oceans. They (mostly) know it’s bad, but if they stopped, they would fall behind. And it doesn’t really matter whether the countries are capitalist inside or not - they are competing against each other.

    I don’t see why it would be different if instead of countries it would be companies competing. If you have two giant companies fishing in ocean, how would you convince one of them to fish less so it doesn’t destroy the whole fish population? Any fish it doesn’t catch is a gift for the competing company. And sure, two companies can make an agreement, but what if there are hundreds of them? You would think it’s logical for all of them to agree on limits so they don’t kill all the fish - that would be the end every single fishing company. But how is that different from what’s happening with climate change right now?

    I’ve seen a video where someone asked a Czech anarcho-capitalist how would the law in ancap work. He responded that the international law is an ancap law. You don’t have a Global State enforcing law on the world’s countries. They do whatever they want on their own property (land), and they form coalitions by free agreement to maintain peace and order and to deal with stuff like climate change.

    Well, when I look at the world right now, I feel like that’s the ultimate argument against ancap. We don’t have anything resembling forever global peace, like some people belived after the cold war. The planet is getting warmer and warmer, despite all the global organizations and agreements. Competion is a competition. I don’t really see a way out other than a global state or global anarchy - the leftist kind of one.

    And I don’t want to start on why I think a global state is a terrible idea - that’s not what you asked - but I’m obviously for the latter.

    • bridgeenjoyer@sh.itjust.worksOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      3 hours ago

      I can see this take but if thats your view the solution is stop having kids (especially if you’re an uneducated redneck) which i agree with. But many people get angry at that.

      • GregorGizeh@lemmy.zip
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        3 hours ago

        Personally i hate that narrative because the ONLY people who would listen to such advice are the very people you need more of, not less. Educated, morally steadfast in the best sense and willing to make a sacrifice on behalf of everyone.

        The people voting against their own interests, perpetuating ignorance and hate, love having kids.

        • bridgeenjoyer@sh.itjust.worksOP
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          edit-2
          3 hours ago

          Right. Its a self perpetuating cycle. But I also dont agree in bringing life into the world that isnt needed. There’s way too many humans already. Just my opinion. Once every single child is adopted, then things could change .

          The good news is future people will be so dumb they wont have any self reflection to realize theyre living in idiocracy !